Energy Minister Dr Megan Woods says she will push for new legislation after meeting leaders from oil giant BP at Parliament.
Earlier this week, a leaked email showed executives were bumping up prices in one area to stem losses. Dr Woods said the email was "alarming" - and called BP to her Parliament office for an urgent 'please explain' meeting.
However Dr Woods says she remains unconvinced, and will be taking further action against this "cynical behaviour".
- BP email puts company in tricky situation - Automobile Association
- Fuel pricing needs greater transparency, says Prime Minister
"I didn't emerge convinced that people were necessarily paying a fair price at the pump," she told The AM Show.
"This might not be a market that's operating in the best interests of consumers."
Dr Woods says a fuel market report last year pointed to "hundreds of millions of dollars" being taken from Kiwi drivers by the fuel companies, but she needs more information.
There is legislation currently before Parliament seeking to give the Commerce Commission greater powers to obtain commercial information of petrol companies in order to regulate them. At the moment, the Commission has no such power.
"We need to equip the Commerce Commission with market-study powers so we can have a proper look at this," she said.
This will "compel" fuel companies to provide data - and Dr Woods told host Duncan Garner she will be ready to take action as soon as she has it.
"What I've also asked officials to begin straight away is a piece of legislation... so once we get the market studies findings in that we have that information," she said.
"If there are regulatory changes that need to be made that we've basically got a piece of legislation that we can plug and play into."
Watch the full interview with Dr Megan Woods above.
The AM Show with Duncan Garner, Amanda Gillies and Mark Richardson, weekdays 6-9am on RadioLIVE and streaming live to the rova app on Android and iPhone.