John Tamihere Column

Popping pills not the only cure for depression

I was amazed to learn about the ongoing inquiry into the death of 17-year-old Toran Henry. Toran was prescribed an anti-depressant widely known as Prozac.

The specialist medical evidence is split right down the middle in regards to whether an anti-depressant was the right medication for this young man.

One line of medical advice says Prozac was good for him, another line of specialist opinion says the evidence is clear Prozac and other anti-depressants can cause anxiety, paranoia, aggression and suicidal tendencies.

You would be equally amazed to know that in a period of five years, anti-depressant prescriptions in this country increased by a whopping 2000%.

Now does this mean there is such a raging epidemic of depression afflicting New Zealanders, they all have to start popping pills?

Life's trials and tribulations are tough, they are stressful, they do cause anxiety – but we don't all have to reach for a pill to solve it or sort it.

One 14-year-old girl I know was taken from 13 years in total immersion kura kaupapa and placed in a mainstream secondary school. She was unwell and her father took her to a GP.

Her father indicated she was old enough to face the consultation by herself and waited in the waiting room.

Fifteen minutes later she walked out with a prescription putting her on Prozac. She took the drug for two days and it turned her into a zombie. Her parents stopped the medication and two weeks after entering her into mainstream school it wasn't as bad as she thought it would be, and her stress and anxiety were put to an end – not by Prozac but by working through her anxiety.

Obviously there will be a requirement for some people to be prescribed anti-depressants.

But we cannot continue to accept that New Zealanders are by a significant number, a walking group of frustrated, tensed-up fruitcakes requiring thousands and thousands of prescriptions for anti-depressants.

Sunday News, February 7, 2010
By Tommy

Lets not go the American way and see a doctor everytime something "wrong" happens in your life. Lets not go the American way and take a "pill" for every symptom we might or might not have. The doctors get a commission probably from the amount of certain drugs they give out. They push the drugs no matter if it works or not. All of them have a warning, "If symptoms persist, see your doctor". Why? So he can mis-diagnose you again? I self medicate and haven't seen a doctor in 5 years, and no panadol type capsule for 2 years. Use common sense.

(0)   (0)
By Tommy

Lets not go the American way and see a doctor everytime something "wrong" happens in your life. Lets not go the American way and take a "pill" for every symptom we might or might not have. The doctors get a commission probably from the amount of certain drugs they give out. They push the drugs no matter if it works or not. All of them have a warning, "If symptoms persist, see your doctor". Why? So he can mis-diagnose you again? I self medicate and haven't seen a doctor in 5 years, and no panadol type capsule for 2 years. Use common sense.

(0)   (0)

Post your opinion

Name:
Email: (Won't be published)
Opinion:
Listen LiveView webcamListen archive



  • Mid-Northland 100.7 FM
  • Whangarei 90.8 FM
  • Rodney 92.9 FM
  • Whangaparaoa 100.2 FM
  • Auckland 100.6 FM / 702 AM
  • Waikato 100.2 FM
  • Whangamata 93.1 FM
  • Bay Of Plenty 1107 AM
  • Whakatane 92.1 FM
  • Rotorua 95.1 FM
  • Gisborne 94.9 FM
  • Taupo 99.2 FM
  • Hawke's Bay 1368 AM
  • Taranaki 89.2 FM
  • Wanganui 96.0 FM
  • Manawatu 93.8 FM
  • Kapiti 99.1 FM
  • Upper Hutt 98.9 FM
  • Wairarapa 98.3 FM
  • Wellington 98.9 FM
  • Nelson 96.0 FM
  • Picton 92.3 FM
  • Blenheim 95.3 FM
  • Westport 90.1 FM
  • Kaikoura 89.1 FM
  • Christchurch 99.3 FM / 738 AM
  • Timaru 89.9 FM
  • Alexandra 95.9 FM
  • Queenstown 91.2 FM
  • Dunedin 96.6 FM
  • Southland 94.0 FM
RSS feeds
Join us on Facebook
Follow us on Twitter
Subscribe to our Top Features Email

Copyright © 2012 MediaWorks Radio. All Rights Reserved.