Prime Minister John Key has been such a good-humoured, sure-footed operator for the last 12 months it’s no surprise he scores so well in the polls. He won’t have done his reputation much harm among his supporters by giving the thumbs-up this week to the Maori flag.
It wasn’t just the decision either. It was also the pleasant, no-fuss way in which he “sold” the idea. He gave the impression it was really no big deal and that it was just a flag. And anyway, New Zealand was united under our conventional, official flag.
He seemed to be saying his true blue National supporters could rest easy – the bros weren’t getting away with anything.
He doesn’t always get things right. And this flag business is trickier than he’s making out.
For one thing, many Maori aren’t thrilled with the way this flag has suddenly become the national Maori flag.
It’s true there were hui here, there and everywhere to help gauge Maori feelings, and it’s true the tino ranga-tiratanga flag won by far the most support.
But it all seemed hasty. So it’s not a move that’ll unite Maori. Not yet anyway.
There’s another problem, though. The flag stands for tino rangatiratanga or Maori sovereignty.
That shouldn’t be a hassle because it was what the Treaty of Waitangi promised in 1840. But it is a headache for John Key’s regime, just as it has been for all his predecessors, because that particular promise was broken almost immediately.
No government has ever been honest enough to own up to the original and continuing treachery.
No government has ever seriously considered sharing the power in the way the treaty spelled out, with the Crown taking care of the “kawanatanga” – in effect, the admin – and Maori holding on to tino rangatiratanga – the authority they had before Governor Hobson stopped off at Wai-tangi.
Let’s not pretend any of the settlements are remotely “full and final”. The iwi who’ve settled have got peanuts by comparison with what the Crown diddled them out of. And none of them got their tino ranga-tiratanga.
This newly appointed flag, however, is a reminder of what we, as Maori, are owed.
So this is the question: Is John Key man enough to deal with what the flag signifies?
Auckland Stuff.co.nz, December 18, 2009